Post by Carillus on Dec 3, 2009 11:36:31 GMT 8
Writers are here arranged in tier rankings, based on how good their roleplay posts are. Those who fall in the lower ranks, please take it as constructive criticism, and improve so that we can all have more fun together.
S Rank
schrodinger
Dialogue bursting with sarcastic wit and splendour. While his characterisation possesses certain elements of being The Chessmaster, it is nonetheless executed with flair and manages to turn what would normally be an utterly detestable trope into one so amusing and instantly likeable that the only description would be AWESOME.
ballistic
From the get-go, his posts reek of philosophical tendencies, but these only serve to set up for the occasional glimpses of witty humour. Solid overall writing that easily expands on characterisation and dishes out a high entertainment value.
A Rank
RaineScarlet
Solid character exploration with powerful inner dialogues. However, some aspects of action could be better written.
Shirafune
While possessing a clear vocabulary and strong writing, a lack of character elaboration and development mars the overall picture.
Carillus
Strong world characterisation and easy perspective shifting. However, suffers from a severe lack of character elaboration, the tendency to pull the Chessmaster and poor sense of power balances.
Protectorate
Strong perspective shifting capabilities and powerful character elaboration. Crisp and clear writing that easily conveys the writer's intention. However, may occasionally run into conversations that go nowhere and are basically filler.
B Rank
luminodrake
Strong understanding of his own characters and a great character creator. However, a mild lack in vocabulary and characterisation prevents this writer from going further than the B rank.
ponpokorin
C Rank
theburntone
While satisfactory in the grammar and vocabulary department, lower-than-average characterisation and a tendency to godmode pulls this writer down to average.
D Rank
Kai-san
ivankira
Jasper Black
E Rank
Mathus
Weak characterisation, tendencies to godmode and a rather weak command of English. It has been noted that while past performance was satisfactory enough to warrant a D rank at least, his recent often senseless, wholly improbable and very boring character performances have pulled him down to E rank.
Qi En
High godmoding tendencies, Mary Sue-like characters, extremely jarring perspective shifts, confusing dialogue and close to zero plot relevance. A desperate overhaul in style might be needed.
S Rank
schrodinger
Dialogue bursting with sarcastic wit and splendour. While his characterisation possesses certain elements of being The Chessmaster, it is nonetheless executed with flair and manages to turn what would normally be an utterly detestable trope into one so amusing and instantly likeable that the only description would be AWESOME.
ballistic
From the get-go, his posts reek of philosophical tendencies, but these only serve to set up for the occasional glimpses of witty humour. Solid overall writing that easily expands on characterisation and dishes out a high entertainment value.
A Rank
RaineScarlet
Solid character exploration with powerful inner dialogues. However, some aspects of action could be better written.
Shirafune
While possessing a clear vocabulary and strong writing, a lack of character elaboration and development mars the overall picture.
Carillus
Strong world characterisation and easy perspective shifting. However, suffers from a severe lack of character elaboration, the tendency to pull the Chessmaster and poor sense of power balances.
Protectorate
Strong perspective shifting capabilities and powerful character elaboration. Crisp and clear writing that easily conveys the writer's intention. However, may occasionally run into conversations that go nowhere and are basically filler.
B Rank
luminodrake
Strong understanding of his own characters and a great character creator. However, a mild lack in vocabulary and characterisation prevents this writer from going further than the B rank.
ponpokorin
C Rank
theburntone
While satisfactory in the grammar and vocabulary department, lower-than-average characterisation and a tendency to godmode pulls this writer down to average.
D Rank
Kai-san
ivankira
Jasper Black
E Rank
Mathus
Weak characterisation, tendencies to godmode and a rather weak command of English. It has been noted that while past performance was satisfactory enough to warrant a D rank at least, his recent often senseless, wholly improbable and very boring character performances have pulled him down to E rank.
Qi En
High godmoding tendencies, Mary Sue-like characters, extremely jarring perspective shifts, confusing dialogue and close to zero plot relevance. A desperate overhaul in style might be needed.
